Which beach should I pick?
In October, Calf Pasture Beach averages 25.0°C and Fire Island averages 16.0°C. The two beaches are 51 km apart on the Atlantic Ocean.
Both beaches are family-friendly with calm, accessible water.
Calf Pasture Beach vs Fire Island
Side-by-side sea temperature, swim score and wave conditions. The two beaches sit roughly 51 km apart.